Loris Zanatta is the author of Storia dell’America Latina contemporanea ( avg rating, 11 ratings, 1 review, published ), Historia de América Lati. The latest Tweets from Loris Zanatta (@LorisZanatta): “Virtus-Hasbrouck, ecco la vera notizia | BOblog: “. Historia De La Iglesia Argentina/ History of the Church in Argentina (Historia Argentina). 1 September by Roberto D. Stefano and Loris Zanatta.
|Published (Last):||27 June 2007|
|PDF File Size:||8.73 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||2.23 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
University of Notre Dame Press, Studies of fascism and nationalism in Argentina have proliferated in the last decade. The publication of Alberto Spektorowski’s new book is an important continuation of this historiographical trend.
Spektorowski stresses the revolutionary dimensions of the Argentine nacionalistas. He questions the idea that nationalist groups in the ‘s and ‘s were mainly conservative or reactionary. For Spektorowski the Argentine nationalists were above all fascists. Following the hypothesis of Zeev Sternhell, Spektorowski understands fascism as an amalgam of extreme right wing nationalism, and anti-Marxist and anti-bourgeois revisions of socialism.
While not excluding its anti-Communist dimensions, he sees fascism as essentially anti-enlightenment and anti-liberal. The book begins with a Sternhellian analysis of European theories of fascism and relates them to the Argentine case. Spektorowski then addresses the Argentine antecedents of the same ideological synthesis of Maurras and Sorel that Sternhell analyzed for Europe.
Spektorowski notes the central role that the fascist poet Leopoldo Lugones—who he aptly describes as an Argentine D’Annunzio—played in this process.
In the most polemical part of his book, Spektorowski stresses the ideological links between right and left within Argentine nationalism. He demonstrates how both, nacionalista and FORJA members did not want liris enter the war on the side of the allies and shared an anti-imperialist vision of international relations.
However Spektorowski does not demonstrate that these groups shared a similar ideological fascist synthesis nor does he address the question of whether this synthesis was part of the actual political experience of rightists and leftists alike. In general, both groups did [End Page ] not partake in political acts together and often saw each other lofis opposites in the political spectrum.
Loris Zanatta (Author of Storia dell’America Latina contemporanea)
Spektorowski’s stress on the Argentine fascists’ social and economic concerns during the thirties is one of the most original aspects of this book. He shows how Argentine fascists’ concerns for economic autarchy and social justice foreshadowed Peronism in both form and substance.
This leads him to his main hypothesis: By way of conclusion, Spektorowski argues that the “first Peronist regime continued the zantata synthesis elaborated by the nationalist right and left while adding a populist slant to it” p. To be sure, Spektorowski’s stress on loeis is illuminating but there were more sui generis elements in Peronism than a mere “populist slant. It tends to emphasize certain ideological tropes, thus occluding certain Peronists particularities that were absent in Argentine fascism i.
Spektorowski also gives limited attention to anti-Semitism. Yet, anti-Semitism was clearly a central facet in Argentine fascist ideology and it was only a minor element in Peronism. These objections notwithstanding, Spektorowski’s work represents an excellent addition to lrois historiography. It reveals the connections between fascism and longstanding tendencies in Argentine political culture.
This is the legacy of Argentina’s revolution of the right. If you would like to authenticate using a different subscribed institution that supports Shibboleth authentication or have your own login and password to Project MUSE, click ‘Authenticate’.
View freely available titles: Book titles OR Journal titles. Project MUSE promotes the creation and dissemination of essential humanities and social science resources through collaboration with libraries, publishers, and scholars worldwide. Forged from a partnership between a university press and a library, Project MUSE poris a trusted part of the academic and scholarly community it serves.
Built on the Johns Hopkins University Campus.
Loris Zanatta — University of Bologna — Teaching material of – International History (LM)
Contact Contact Us Help.